23,761 Meals Donated

4,188 Blankets Donated

10,153 Toys Donated

13,088 Rescue Miles Donated

$2,358 Funded For D.V. Survivors

$7,059 Funded For Service Dogs

Search
Close this search box.

Anti-bark Collar: Beneficial or Harmful?

We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more.

Share this:

An anti-bark collar is a tool commonly used to reduce or prevent unwanted barking in dogs. In this guide, you’ll learn all you need to know about anti-bark collars.

We generally advise against using an anti-bark collar except in very rare cases. It’s better to try other proven training methods, and only as a last resort should you consider it.

What is an Anti-bark Collar?

Anti-bark Collar
Source: Freepik

Does your dog bark at everyone passing by? Does he bark when the doorbell rings, being the first to give a barking response?

In general, your dog’s barking should not be stopped with an anti-bark collar. Because his barking could be a sign that there is a threat!

Your dog needs to learn when not to bark.

Some of us opt for an anti-bark collar in such situations. It aims to negatively reinforce the barking behavior and eventually teach the dog to avoid this behavior over time.

Anti-bark collars are collars designed to prevent unwanted barking in dogs. They can work in various ways, such as through vibration, ultrasonic sound, or electric stimulation.

Some anti-bark collars emit an electric shock when the dog barks. This type of collar is referred to as an “electric shock collar” and has been controversial in the past. There are concerns about the safety and potentially painful nature of the electric shock.

Anti-bark collars can also have negative effects on the dog’s behavior and well-being. They can cause the dog to experience fear, stress, or pain and even develop behavioral problems such as aggression or anxiety disorders.

There are many alternative training methods and approaches to behavior modification based on positive reinforcement, reward, and building a bond between dog and owner. It’s important to seek professional advice and carefully consider which training aids and collars are best for the dog to ensure his safety and well-being.

What types of anti-bark collars are there?

There are several types of anti-bark collars. In terms of technical anti-bark training, they are as follows:

Spray

Gives your dog a small spray that stops the annoying barking. This function is activated when the sound of barking or the vibration of the vocal cords is detected.

  • Not triggered inappropriately
  • Affordable
  • Easy training for dogs
  • Effective scent
  • If the dog turns its head, it doesn’t get any spray

Vibration

Designed to give the dog an uncomfortable but safe vibration correction at irregular intervals. This is to prevent the dog from getting used to the stimulation. This type of collar is best for dogs that are fearful or have a sensitive temperament.

If you want to take control yourself, there are remote-controlled vibration collars. You can activate it remotely only when you deem it necessary, and after a few training sessions, your pet will understand what it’s about.

  • Stops vibrating only when the dog hasn’t barked for a while
  • Can be triggered by the dog’s movement
  • Confusing

Ultrasonic

Designed to emit a very high and unpleasant tone that only dogs can hear. This type of collar is commonly used for smaller breeds.

  • Inaudible to humans
  • Can be triggered by other ambient noises
  • Confusing

Electric

These anti-bark systems are widely used abroad and are considered very effective. However, it is by no means our recommendation, as it is also prohibited under animal welfare laws in the United States. Certainly not without reason.

Some studies suggest that the electric shock from the shock collars can lead to aggression, stress, or persistent anxiety in dogs.

How to properly put on the collar

So, you’ve chosen a product. But you’re frustrated because it’s not working properly. While there are defective collars due to production, there are also those that don’t work due to faulty operation.

To eliminate operator error, pay attention to these procedures!

When putting on the collar, it must make contact with the dog’s skin.

For the first fitting, it’s important that the collar sits high on the dog’s neck. It should be below the jawline area. This is important because it’s the narrowest part of the neck.

If the collar fits properly, it won’t be able to slip into a different position.

If you attach the band to the thickest part of the neck, over time, it will slide to the narrowest part. It will then be too loose and stop working. The anti-bark collar should sit under the dog’s neck. The box points downward and the probes inward.

All vibration-activated collars must detect barking. They must also sit in this position. If the collar moves away from this area, it won’t be able to detect barking!

Not too tight, not too loose

This is probably where most people run into trouble. Anti-bark collars must be tighter than a regular leather or nylon collar. Remember that a dog has a very robust neck, much tougher than ours.

The collar is not intended to obstruct the dog’s breathing. However, it must be secure so it doesn’t shift. This can vary from dog to dog depending on the structure and size of the neck.

The thickness of the dog can also play a crucial role in a collar not working properly. The metal probes may sometimes have difficulty getting through the hair.

In some cases, you may need to trim or shave a piece of hair if this is the case. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions step by step.

These are the features to look out for

  • Manufacturer’s Warranty
  • Waterproof Collar: An anti-bark collar should be completely waterproof and submersible to ensure the safety of the dog in unforeseen circumstances involving water.
  • Small and Compact: The collar should be small, compact, and lightweight, making it comfortable and easy for the dog to wear and train with.

Alternatives

Source: Freepik

Dogs can bark as a learned response.

Your dog barks and then receives attention from you.

So, he learns: Barking gets him what he wants. If your dog brings you his toy and barks, you play with him.

So, he feels: Barking is a good way to play. Barking is a normal play behavior of a dog. It can be directed at either a person or an animal.

In line with barking for attention, dogs may also bark in response to fear. They feel this when the owner is absent.

This typically occurs immediately after the dog owner leaves the house. This is called separation anxiety.

Barking can persist for several hours. It usually only happens when the owner is absent.

For many, one of the above causes is reason enough to justify the use of an anti-bark collar.

Such a collar should never be used when:

  • Dogs are in pain
  • Deaf
  • Have cognitive problems
  • or suffer from brain disorders

Because these dogs can also bark excessively.

To rule out these possibilities: Always take your dog to a veterinarian beforehand! Do not start a behavior modification program beforehand! Also, do not use an anti-bark collar.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the choice of an anti-bark collar is up to you. You are responsible for the well-being and health of your dog.

However, you must also conscientiously be responsible for the well-being of your neighbors and your family.

Try out alternative methods of behavior modification before selecting a collar. Your veterinarian can recommend specific exercises to train with your dog.

In reason, barking is a natural behavior for a dog. However, it should be closely monitored.

Learn to recognize the triggers that cause your dear friend to bark. And work on eliminating as many of these stressors as possible.

Training the dog to stop barking may seem like a time-consuming burden. However, it can often prove more successful than just using an anti-bark collar.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should such a collar be worn?

The collar should not be worn on your dog daily. It’s best to plan ahead how to train your pet. This way, you can more effectively stop barking. Some refresh weekly.

Use entertainment toys or treats. Your dog focuses his attention on the toy. Your friend forgets to bark unnecessarily. Because you keep him mentally active and busy with the toy.

We do not recommend leaving the collar on your dog’s neck 24 hours a day. Important: Read the manufacturer’s instructions carefully and follow them!

Is an anti-bark collar absolutely necessary?

Our personal opinion:

Consider alternatives to anti-bark collars. Use traditional disciplinary measures or other means.

This does not cause physical or emotional pain or stress. If possible, discipline dogs naturally.

Share this:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *