Kelly Clarkson and John Legend, judges on The Voice, usually focus on singing talent rather than politics. But a recent episode stirred up some controversy. During Gyth Rigdon’s performance of “God Bless the USA,” both Clarkson and Legend found themselves in hot water.
The two judges had some criticisms about Rigdon’s song choice. Although their feedback was honest and aimed at helping him improve, fans on Twitter were not happy.
They felt that criticizing Rigdon’s performance of such a patriotic song seemed out of touch with the current political climate. As one fan tweeted, “You can’t judge a song like ‘God Bless the USA’ without seeming unpatriotic!”
Clarkson, known for her down-to-earth personality, acknowledged how tricky it was to critique a song so deeply tied to national pride. She even joked about the challenge, saying, “It’s like trying to criticize a flag!”
Despite their praise for Rigdon’s heartfelt connection to the song, the judges didn’t hold back on their opinions about his vocal performance.
Some viewers thought the judges were too harsh or unfair. This situation highlights how tricky it can be for judges to balance honest feedback with respecting a performer’s emotional attachment to their song.
It also shows how different people can have very different opinions about what’s acceptable or meaningful in art.
Watch the video down below:
Share your thoughts in the comments down below!
