Many of us have dreamed about stumbling across hidden treasure at a flea market or garage sale—something rare or valuable that no one else noticed. Who hasn’t thought about finding a priceless artifact or old painting for the price of a cup of coffee?

I know I have, and stories of people who’ve actually done it only make me hope more! Maybe you’ve heard about someone buying a painting for a few dollars, only to find out it was by a famous artist. It happens!

Of course, “treasure” can mean different things. Most people think of pirate loot—chests overflowing with gold coins and sparkling jewels. But for others, old family photographs and documents can be just as precious. These items often tell incredible stories, and sometimes they’re worth much more than we realize.

That’s exactly what happened to Randy Guijarro. One day, Randy stopped at a garage sale and bought an old photo album for just $2. The album seemed to hold pretty ordinary memories, but something inside it would turn out to be extraordinary.

The black-and-white photos in the album were clearly old, judging by their style and the fact that they weren’t in color. But no one could’ve guessed what one of those photos actually captured.

Randy didn’t realize it at first either. He bought the box of photos simply because he thought they looked cool and unique. Later, when he got home, he started going through them—and that’s when he found something unbelievable.

As he flipped through the album, Randy suddenly spotted a familiar face. It was none other than Billy the Kid, one of the Wild West’s most infamous outlaws! Billy the Kid, whose real name was William H. Bonney, had become legendary for his life of crime and his ability to stay one step ahead of the law. He was shot and killed in 1881 at just 23 years old, leaving behind stories of daring escapes and gunfights.

But this photo wasn’t just a glimpse of a notorious figure from history—it was also incredibly valuable.

According to reports, the image Randy found, which he had picked up for only $2, could be worth up to $5 million! That’s right—$5 million for a single photo, tucked away in an old album at a random garage sale.

It’s the kind of discovery you wouldn’t believe unless you saw it for yourself, and it’s proof that treasures really can be hiding in the most unexpected places.

You can see more about this amazing find in the video below:

What would you do if you found something like this? Share your thoughts in the comments!