When my father died, the only thing he left me in his will was a locked toolbox. No jewelry, no money, no land—just that rusty blue box with a heavy padlock on it.
At first, I thought maybe Dad had lost his mind in his final days. Why would he leave me such a strange thing? But a few days after the funeral, my stepmother, April, showed up at my doorstep—and what she said made me realize that toolbox was hiding something big.
April walked in without even waiting for me to invite her. She had that smile on her face—the one I’d seen a thousand times before—that smile that always meant she was plotting something.
“Marla, honey,” she said sweetly, her eyes sliding instantly to the toolbox sitting near the front door. “That rusty old thing is going to flake all over your carpet. You really should just throw it out.”
I raised my eyebrows, surprised at her sudden interest. “Dad left it to me. I figure he must’ve had a reason.”
April tilted her head and gave a soft laugh. “I’ll tell you what—get rid of it, and I’ll give you $5,000 cash right now.”
My heart skipped. “Wait. You’ll pay me to throw away a beat-up old toolbox?”
She shrugged, pretending to be casual, but her eyes didn’t match her voice. “I just feel bad you didn’t get much from the will. You deserve something meaningful, not an old box of junk. Come by tomorrow, I’ll let you pick another keepsake of your dad’s.”
I stared at her. April was offering me thousands of dollars for something she claimed was worthless. That didn’t make sense.
“Thanks, April,” I said carefully, “but I think I’ll hold on to it.”
Her smile faltered. For a second, I saw fear flash across her face before she forced her usual calm expression back.
“Suit yourself,” she muttered, shoving the envelope of cash back into her purse. “It’s not like you even have the key. Your father lost that years ago.”
But her quick answer and the way her eyes darted away told me everything—I knew she was lying.
The next day, I tried everything to break into that box. Bolt cutters? No luck. A hammer? Nothing. I even tried picking the lock with a bobby pin like they do in movies. It didn’t even budge.
I sat on the floor, sweaty and frustrated, staring at it. I was convinced April had the key. And if I knew April, she’d be keeping something that important tucked away in her jewelry box.
So, I came up with a plan.
I dialed her number and tried to sound casual. “Hi, April. I’ve been thinking about your offer. Maybe I should look through Dad’s things after all, just in case there’s something I’d rather keep.”
Her tone brightened instantly. “Of course, honey! Come by this afternoon. I’ll make us some tea.”
That afternoon, I sat across from her in her living room. She pulled out boxes of Dad’s things, showing me one item after another.
“Here are his cufflinks from his father,” she said, holding them up proudly. “And this is the gold watch he got when he retired.”
I nodded, pretending to care, but all I could think about was getting into her bedroom.
“Excuse me,” I said after finishing half my tea, “I need to use the bathroom.”
“Of course, honey. You know where it is.”
Instead of heading to the bathroom, I slipped into her bedroom. My heart was pounding as I opened the dresser drawer. There it was—her jewelry box.
Inside, nestled between her rings and bracelets, I spotted a small key. It had the same brand name as the padlock on my toolbox. My hands shook as I grabbed it and tucked it into my pocket.
When I returned to the living room, April had more of Dad’s things laid out on the table.
I pretended to consider his tie, then sighed. “This is a big decision. I’ll need more time.”
“Of course,” she said smoothly, though her eyes studied me like she didn’t quite trust me.
I finished my tea and hurried home. The moment I closed my front door, I pulled out the key and slid it into the padlock.
Click.
The lock opened.
My heart raced as I lifted the lid.
At first, it looked like nothing. Just tools—screwdrivers, a flashlight, hex keys, wrenches. I frowned.
“This can’t be it,” I whispered.
I dug deeper, moving tray after tray, until my fingers hit something flat at the very bottom. Wrapped in thick plastic was an envelope.
I tore it open.
Inside were divorce papers. My parents’ divorce papers. Except here’s the thing—Dad always told me my mother had died when I was two.
But these papers proved she hadn’t.
Her name—Susannah—was written clearly. The reason for divorce: “Irreconcilable differences caused by instability and unsafe behavior.”
I read it three times before it sank in. Dad had lied. My mother hadn’t died. She had been alive.
And April knew it.
I stormed back to April’s house without calling. When she opened the door, I held up the stolen key.
Her face drained of color. “You opened it.”
“And I found the papers. You and Dad lied to me. He told me my mother was dead.”
For once, April’s calm mask slipped. She actually looked rattled.
“He made me promise not to tell you. It was for your own good, Marla.”
“My own good? How is lying about my own mother good for me?”
April clenched her jaw. “Because she wasn’t safe. After you were born, she… changed. She didn’t believe you were real sometimes. Your father said she would disappear for days. He had her admitted to a mental hospital, but she ran away. That’s when he divorced her.”
“Postpartum psychosis?” I whispered, remembering something I’d once read.
April shrugged. “Maybe that’s what started it, but it got worse. Your father tried everything. But in the end, he thought it was better if you never knew.”
Tears stung my eyes. “So all this time, I thought she was gone, and she was alive.”
“Alive, yes. But not someone you needed in your life. I’ve been more of a mother to you than she ever was!” April snapped.
I looked at her, really looked, and realized the truth. “You were scared I’d go looking for her. That’s why you wanted me to throw the toolbox away.”
April didn’t deny it. She just looked away in silence.
I turned to leave. “That woman,” I said firmly, “is still my mother. And I deserve to know what happened to her.”
It took me three days of searching online records, newspapers, and databases before I found her.
And when I did, my heart broke all over again.
She had died. Just the year before.
All those years wasted. I would never meet her, never hear her side of the story.
But I could at least visit her grave.
I walked through the cemetery until I found her headstone. It was simple: her name, her birth and death dates.
Someone had left daisies that were dried and brown. I replaced them with the white roses I’d brought.
“I’m so sorry,” I whispered. “I wish I’d had the chance to know you. But I wasn’t even given the choice.”
I cried—really cried—for the mother I never knew.
That’s when I heard footsteps behind me.
I turned, and an older woman stood there. She gasped, pressing her hand to her heart.
“Marla?” she whispered. “You look so much like Susannah… it must be you!”
My breath caught. “You knew my mother?”
Tears filled her eyes. “I’m Tanya. Susannah was my sister. That makes me your aunt.”
My chest tightened. “I didn’t even know she had a sister. Dad cut all of you off.”
“Oh, honey,” Tanya said, pulling me into a hug. “Your mother struggled, yes, but she loved you so much. On her good days, she never stopped missing you.”
I sobbed into her shoulder. “She… she asked about me?”
“All the time,” Tanya said softly. “She loved you fiercely.”
For the first time in days, my tears weren’t only from pain.
Tanya squeezed my hands. “Let’s get some coffee. I’ll tell you everything about her. You deserve to know.”
And for the first time in my life, I realized I wasn’t alone. I had family—real family—I never knew existed. And maybe, through Tanya’s stories, I could finally piece together the truth about the mother I had been denied all my life.